The Etiquette of Pulling the Pin: When and Why You Should (or Shouldn’t) Do It

In the world of golf, etiquette is as essential as a solid swing. One of the more debated aspects of golf etiquette involves the flagstick—or “the pin”—and whether or not it should be pulled from the hole before putting. In recent years, rules around the flagstick have changed, allowing golfers to leave it in or take it out while putting. This shift has sparked a range of opinions on what’s best for play and proper etiquette. So, let’s dive into the considerations for pulling the pin and whether it’s a good idea.

Understanding the Rules

In 2019, the USGA (United States Golf Association) amended the Rules of Golf to allow players to putt with the flagstick in the hole without incurring a penalty. This rule change was intended to speed up the pace of play and give golfers more flexibility in their approach. Now, players can leave the pin in for long putts or remove it for short ones based on their comfort level and strategic choice.

Pros of Leaving the Pin In

1. Pace of Play: Leaving the pin in can speed up the game, which is especially beneficial during busy days on the course. Instead of waiting for someone to pull the pin, players can keep putting as soon as they’re ready. For casual rounds or when playing in a group, this can make a noticeable difference in the flow of the game.

2. Helpful on Longer Putts: Some golfers believe that leaving the pin in can serve as a visual aid for longer putts. It helps them aim better, and there’s even an argument that the pin might help stop a ball that would otherwise roll past the hole.

3. Newer Golfers Feel More Comfortable: For beginners or those still developing their confidence on the greens, the pin can serve as a point of reference. It provides reassurance and reduces the pressure of judging the distance, especially on longer putts.

Cons of Leaving the Pin In

1. Distraction on Short Putts: On short putts, the pin can sometimes be more of a distraction than a help. It can cast a shadow or make the hole look smaller, leading some players to feel less confident about sinking their putts.

2. Risk of Rebound: A strong putt that strikes the pin might ricochet out of the hole, especially if it’s hit with too much pace. For those who putt more aggressively, this could mean a missed opportunity to score.

3. Etiquette Concerns: In some cases, playing partners may have strong opinions about pulling the pin. If someone in your group prefers the pin out, it’s polite to oblige when it’s their turn to putt. Golf is a game of respect, and being considerate of others’ preferences can go a long way in maintaining harmony on the course.

The Etiquette of Pulling the Pin

When it comes to pulling the pin, it’s all about communication and respecting the preferences of your playing partners. Here are a few key etiquette points to consider:

1. Ask Before Acting: Before pulling the pin or leaving it in, ask your playing partners what they prefer. A simple, “Do you want the pin in or out?” shows consideration and ensures everyone is on the same page.

2. Consider the Pace of Play: If you’re in a group and everyone is fine with the pin staying in, it’s often best to leave it in to keep things moving. On the other hand, if someone is ready to pull the pin while others are still getting ready, they should be mindful of not holding up the group.

3. Be Mindful of the Situation: In windy conditions, the flagstick can sway and become a distraction. In such cases, it’s courteous to pull the pin, especially for those with short putts. Likewise, if the cup is full of debris, take the opportunity to clean it out while pulling the pin.

4. Know When to Speak Up: If you have a strong preference for having the pin in or out, don’t be afraid to voice it—politely. Most golfers will respect your choice, especially when you’re the one putting.

Is It a Good Idea to Pull the Pin?

The answer largely depends on the situation and personal preference. For longer putts, leaving the pin in might provide some advantages and speed up play. For shorter putts, especially when precision is key, pulling the pin may be the better option. Ultimately, the best decision is the one that aligns with your confidence, comfort, and the flow of the game.

Conclusion

Whether you’re a traditionalist who prefers the pin out or someone who likes the speed and simplicity of leaving it in, the most important thing is to respect the game and your fellow golfers. Golf is as much about etiquette and respect as it is about skill, so always communicate and be considerate of others’ preferences when it comes to pulling the pin.

By understanding the pros and cons, and practicing good etiquette, you’ll keep the game enjoyable for everyone—whether the pin stays in or comes out.

Mary-Anne H.  Toronto